Bevel Gear Grid Dependency Test for FEA using ANSYS Workbench

  • Objectives:  To perform a Grid Dependency Test on Bevel Gear to get optimum results.

 

  • Geometrical Design:

We are having a Bevel Gear assembly which will be used to analyse for FEA, take a look at geometry below;

 

As we are working for Grid Dependency, we also focussed on Geometry Clean up, the inner solid portion is removed so that mesh density will reduce and will lead to less computational time.

Here is the final geometry for analysis.

 

 

  • Material Properties:

We have taken Structural Steel as material for Bevel Gears;

 

  • Problem Statement:

Bevel Gear Assembly is analysed with ANSYS Workbench for FEA to obtain Grid Dependency.

Considering the analysis point of view, we will work for 3 cases in this project, we will try to analyse three different sizes of mesh, 1) 5 mm, 2) 4 mm, 3) 3 mm.  Gears are named as per their size Small Gear & Big Gear.

Before checking the Analysis results, let’s have some briefing about GRID DEPENDENCY

What is Grid Dependency?

  • Grid Dependency is the method used in CAE to get optimum results by reducing mesh density in a given component.
  • Grid Dependency, Mesh Refinement or Scaling are similar words used in FEA & CFD analysis.
  • Initially, FEA process starts with the Default or Coarse Mesh after obtaining the results, a mesh is refined in areas of interest which will give appropriate results.
  • This process is followed until the user gets optimised results for a given problem. When there is no significant change in Equivalent Stress and Equivalent Elastic Strain we can say that the mesh refinement is achieved, further mesh refinement will not show drastic change in values of Stress and Strain.
  • When the mesh size becomes smaller it will lead to higher computational time. There can be an issue with Force Convergence as well.
  • The results obtained by mesh refinement give accurate result close to realistic results.
  • Grid Dependency means not only reduction of mesh size, but we can achieve it by Linear or Quadric Elements, it also depends on Geometry as well.

Let’s focus on project again,

  • Boundary Conditions:

Both the gears provided with Friction and Joint Contacts. Analysis is carried out in 6 steps; Small Gear is applied with joint rotation up to 1200 and Big Gear is constrained with 100 N-mm moments in each step.

Have look at constraints

 

 

  • Analysis:

 Case: 1 (Mesh Size 5 mm)

 

  • Mesh Criterion:

In this analysis we kept 5 mm mesh on Gear Body and on the Gear Teeth we kept 1.75 mm mesh.

  • Element Quality:

 

  • Analysis Settings:

 

 

Case: 2 (Mesh Size 4 mm)

 

  • Mesh Criterion:

In this analysis we kept 4 mm mesh on Gear Body and on the Gear Teeth we kept 1.75 mm mesh.

  • Element Quality:

 

  • Analysis Settings:

 Same analysis settings taken from Case 1

 

Case: 3 (Mesh Size 3 mm)

 

  • Mesh Criterion:

In this analysis we kept 3 mm mesh on Gear Body and on the Gear Teeth we kept 1.75 mm mesh.

  • Element Quality:

  • Analysis Settings:

 Same analysis settings taken from Case 1

 

 

  • Post Processing:

 

  • Case: 1 (Mesh Size 5 mm)

Total Deformation:

Equivalent Elastic Strain:

Equivalent Stress:

 

  • Case: 2 (Mesh Size 4 mm)

Total Deformation:

Equivalent Elastic Strain:

Equivalent Stress:

 

  • Case: 3 (Mesh Size 3 mm)

Total Deformation:

Equivalent Elastic Strain:

Equivalent Stress:

 

Here is a link for the Animation of this Project,

Bevel Gear FEA | Ansys Academic

 

Post Process Results Summary;

  • Results and Conclusion:

1) Total Deformation is Similar in all three cases.

2) The values of Equivalent Elastic Strain is decreasing when we decrease the mesh size, there is a small change in values of strain.

3) Same as strain, Equivalent Stress value also changes with the mesh size.

 

We can clearly see that the result obtained with 3 mm mesh is a bit similar to 5 mm mesh so we can say that 3 mm mesh results are accurate and close to realistic results.

 


Projects by Vishal Joshi

Objectives:  To analyze metal sheet rolling operation in Ansys workbench   Geometrical Design: For this analysis, we have a 3D model that consists of various parts such as Roller 1, Roller 2 and workpiece. This is how the whole assembly looks like; Read more

Objectives: To perform Wire Bending Operation in Ansys workbench. Geometrical Design: We are having 3D Geometry of Wire Bending Simulation model. This model consists of three main parts named as Support, Metal Wire & Lever. This geometry looks like this; Read more

Objectives:  To perform explicit analysis in bullet penetrating bucket challenge   Geometrical Design: For this analysis we have a 3D Geometry of Bullet and Bucket, this is how model looks like.   Material Properties: In this analysis 3 different Read more

Objectives:  To perform Sheet Metal Bending Operation in ANSYS Workbench Geometrical Design: 3D Model is shown below; it is having 3 main parts named as Punch Die and Sheet.   Material Properties: For this analysis we will consider 3 different material Read more

Objective: To perform Car Crash Analysis using ANSYS Workbench.   Geometrical Design: We are having a Car Body & Wall 3D Model. This looks something like this,     To reduce simulation time & computational time, only half portion of ge Read more

Objectives: To analyze Worm and Gear Assembly for Stress Analysis.   Geometrical Design: For this project we have two parts in assembly named as Worm & Gear. This is how full geometry looks like,     For the sake of FE Analysis we will lo Read more

Objectives: To analyze Machining Process in Planer Machine with Explicit Dynamic Module   Geometrical Design: Assembly for this project contains a work piece of Steel and a Cutting Tool used in Planer Machine, parts of this assembly looks like this. &nb Read more

Objectives: To analyse Slider Crank Mechanism for Stress & Modal Analysis   Geometrical Design: The model for Slider Crank Mechanism looks like this consists of various parts such as Member, Crank, Part 1 and Part 2. Material Properties: For th Read more

Objectives: To analyse Carbon Steel Specimen for Tension & Torsion Test.   Why Tension & Torsion Test carried out? Tension and Torsion test are most important tests that are carried out on a specimen to obtain various mechanical properties of materia Read more

Objectives: To analyse barrel cam and follower for stress, strain analysis. Geometrical Design: For this analysis we have geometry which contains three major parts named as Barrel, Barrel Cam and Cam Follower. This is how geometry looks like;   Mater Read more


Loading...

The End